Editor’s Note: I received an email today with updated information regarding the Hope Steffey case—the video we posted a while back showing male cops removing a female’s clothing. I read the information but knew there was even more up-to-date information. This story is from the local paper and is more in depth. Since this was written, most of the lawsuits have been settled for undisclosed amounts with the county expecting to have to pay over $100,000, but we do not know how much over $100,000. The Grand Jury cleared the sheriff’s department; however, now a number of other women have come forward complaining of similar treatment.
By Shane Hoover
Posted Sep 28, 2008 @ 05:31 PM
Last update Jul 13, 2009 @ 05:56 PM
CANTON —
The woman’s screams echoed in the isolation cell.
“I didn’t do anything wrong. What am I here for? What are you doing?” Hope Steffey yelled as male and female deputies pinned her to the cell floor and stripped away her clothes.
The deputies told her she was going on suicide precautions, and they documented the incident on video. But when a Cleveland TV station aired a portion of that video in February, more people had questions: Why did this happen? How did an alleged assault victim end up naked in a jail cell?
Criticism, outrage and even death threats against sheriff’s deputies poured in from around the country and overseas.
A state investigation and grand jury review found no criminal wrongdoing, but prompted more questions: Was the probe thorough? Was there another side to the story?
The incident occurred in October 2006, but those questions remain as Sheriff Tim Swanson runs for re-election.
A review of video and audio recordings and more than 600 pages of documents The Repository obtained through public records requests sheds more light on the case, now in civil litigation in federal court.
The case can be broken into three parts: Steffey’s arrest, her incarceration and the state’s subsequent investigation.
Steffey, 42, of Salem, and her attorneys deny that she was suicidal. They accuse sheriff’s deputies of assaulting her, illegally strip-searching her and leaving her naked for six hours in a cell. Her attorneys declined to be interviewed for this story, but their complaints are outlined in documents filed in U.S. District Court in which they say Steffey has lasting physical and emotional injuries.
The sheriff’s office says Steffey was combative and had to be placed on suicide and homicide precautions to prevent her from harming herself or others. Forcibly removing an inmate’s clothing and belongings in that situation doesn’t constitute a strip-search because the purpose is not to find evidence or contraband, Swanson argues.
To read the rest of the story, click here.